Opening hotel

Island City House Hotel

9.1/10Excellent · 977 reviews

411 William Street, Key West

Island City House Hotel, photo 1
1/6

Choose your room

  • Island City House One-Bedroom Suite · Sleeps up to 4 · 1 Sofa bed, 1 Queen bed
  • Island City House Queen Suite w/ Porch · Sleeps up to 2 · 1 Queen Bed, 1 Sofa bed
  • Island City Queen Porch · Sleeps up to 2 · 1 Queen bed
  • Two-Bedroom Suite (Arch House) · Sleeps up to 6 · 1 Sofa bed, 2 Queen bed
  • Deluxe Queen Suite · Sleeps up to 2 · 1 Queen bed, 1 Sofa bed
  • Arch House Garden View Studio w/ Balcony · Sleeps up to 2 · 1 Queen Bed

About

Enchanting families and groups since 1912, Island City House Hotel is Key West, Florida's most welcoming destination for relaxation and escape. Our three historical buildings are encapsulated in a rich heritage and offer comfortable accommodations for various travelers, including families. Centrally located, our property offers easy access to all the adventure and excitement that Key West offers, including water activities, shopping, dining, and sightseeing. We offer a delightful inground swimming pool surrounded by lush, beautiful landscaping creating an oasis that beckons guests to unwind and enjoy the island life. Guests choose from three distinct lodging settings: The Arch House, The Island City House, and The Cigar House. The Island City House is the property's primary building with eleven suites (studio, one-bedroom or two-bedroom) featuring Victorian island-style furnishings, lace curtains and antique pieces. The Arch House has six suites in a laid-back Caribbean style, with two-bedroom suites offering living rooms with dining areas, full kitchens and cozy porches, and studio suites with kitchenettes and either a street-side balcony with a porch swing or a garden-view balcony with a hammock. The Cigar House, set poolside, frames five spacious one-bedroom suites in a timeless tropical plantation style with separate living rooms, full kitchens and pool views from a porch or balcony.

Amenities

Outdoor Pool
Free Parking
Wi-Fi
Guest Laundry
Concierge Service
Onsite Massage
Bike Rental
Widow's Walk
Tropical garden with waterfall and Koi ponds
Pool deck with chaise lounges
Patio tables
Loading zone
Luggage storage
HDTVs/Flat-Screen TVs
Sofa Bed
Mini-fridge
Kitchenettes
Full Kitchen/Full Fridge
Microwave
Coffee Maker
Free WiFi
Non-smoking rooms
Air conditioning
Heating
Terrace
Family rooms
Garden
Laundry
Fax/photocopying
Tour desk
Facilities for disabled guests
Sun terrace
Private check-in/check-out
Daily housekeeping
Designated smoking area
Heated pool
Outdoor furniture
Shallow end
Fence around pool
Cashless payment available
Key access

Good to know

Check-in after 3:00 PM · Check-out before 11:00 AM

No pets · Children welcome · Parking: not_available

Guests must be 25 years of age or older to book.Please note that all cancelations are subject to a cancelation fee. Contact the property for more details.The hours of operation to include the last same-day booking will be taken until 6pm.Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.Please inform of your expected arrival time in advance. You can use the Special Requests box when booking, or contact the property directly using the contact details in your confirmation.Managed by a private hostA deposit may be required at the property.

Location

Map showing Island City House Hotel

411 William Street, Key West

Reviews

9.1/10Excellent977 reviews

Review highlights

Very clean and well-maintained groundsExcellent central location, close to Duval Street/HarbourBeautiful tropical garden and colonial-style buildingsPleasant poolFriendly and helpful staffIn-room kitchens / good for groupsRooms can be damp; guests requested dehumidifiersSmall rooms for families and uncomfortable sofa bedLow water pressure in some showersMaintenance needs (pool fencing, laundry area)Occasional small bugs around kitchen sinkStairs to rooms
Cleanliness9.6/10
Consistently praised across reviews — described as very clean with well-maintained rooms and grounds.
Service9.5/10
Staff repeatedly noted as friendly, available and 'amazing'; daily housekeeping and helpful service mentioned.
Location9.7/10
Multiple comments highlight an excellent central location: short walk to Duval Street/Harbour yet tucked away and quiet.
Room Quality8.0/10
Mixed feedback: comfortable beds and some large rooms reported, but issues include dampness in rooms, uncomfortable sofa-bed for families, small rooms for groups, and occasional low shower water pressure.
Amenities9.0/10
Pool, tropical garden, in-room kitchens and laundry are praised; some maintenance issues noted (pool fencing, laundry) and requests for dehumidifiers in rooms.

Summary written by Anywayr from 977 guest reviews.

CherieNovember 2026 · Couple

9.0/10

This is our 2nd stay and overall love ICH The convienance of bike rental on site

Didn't like: The bed was smaller than preferred

ElaineOctober 2026 · Couple

10.0/10

Fabulous and so convenient, 8 mins walk from all the actio Very clean and so ‘Key West’ historical home x

ElizabethOctober 2026 · Solo traveller

10.0/10

Great location tucked away in the trees but close to everything! Quiet and close to everything

Didn't like: Small bugs around kitchen sink but to be expected in Florida

PattyOctober 2026 · Couple

10.0/10

I would diffently recommend the island city house The grounds were beautiful very clean and perfect location

Didn't like: Water pressure in the shower

PattyOctober 2026 · Couple

10.0/10

Loved it Beautiful property nicely maintained rooms clean outside very well maintained

Didn't like: Nothing everything was great

WillOctober 2026 · Couple

10.0/10

Great landscape and close to everything and comfortable beds and room.

fryerOctober 2026 · Couple

10.0/10

The best hotel in the Keys! Everything. It was literally perfect in everyway. I was on vacation from the UK and whilst in Orlando my dog passed away and I was heartbroken I couldnt be there for him but Island City House was the perfect, peaceful getaway I needed to relax and calm down and the staff were amazing! I will hopefully be back next summer.

RyanSeptember 2026 · Extended group

10.0/10

Loved our stay! Wish we could’ve stayed longer! Beautiful property, nice big rooms with everything you need, awesome pool, and close to Duval Street

JanetteSeptember 2026 · Family with children

7.0/10

Great location, Short walk to Harbour area or Duval Street.

Didn't like: Room was small for Family of 4, had to use sofa bed. Cant remember if this was made clear at time of booking but as only a short trip we put up with it.

JinitAugust 2026 · Solo traveller

10.0/10

Top service...

Nearby hotels in Key West