Opening hotel

Amsterdam's Curry Mansion Inn

9.2/10Excellent · 195 reviews

511 Caroline St, Key West, Florida, 33040, Key West

Amsterdam's Curry Mansion Inn, photo 1
1/50

Choose your room

  • Classic Queen · Sleeps up to 2 · 1 Queen Bed
  • King Suite · Sleeps up to 4 · 1 King bed, 2 Trundle bed
  • King Suite Balcony - James House · Sleeps up to 4 · 1 King bed, 2 Trundle bed
  • Deluxe Queen · Sleeps up to 4 · 2 Queen Bed
  • Classic King Balcony · Sleeps up to 2 · 1 King bed
  • Classic King Balcony - James House · Sleeps up to 2 · 1 King bed

About

Outdoor Pool and Terrace Enjoy the serene atmosphere by taking a dip in the outdoor pool or relax on the terrace and garden with beautiful views. Complimentary Amenities Stay connected with free Wi-Fi, make use of concierge services, and enjoy a picnic area. Shuttle services to nearby attractions make exploring easy. Elegant Accommodations Individually decorated guestrooms with private pools and premium bedding offer a luxurious stay. Modern conveniences like wireless internet and separate sitting areas ensure a comfortable visit. Experience the charm of a Victorian bed & breakfast centrally located in Key West. Steps away from Duval Street and other major attractions, book your stay at Amsterdam's Curry Mansion Inn now!

Amenities

Elevator
Golfing nearby
Snorkeling nearby
Surfing/bodyboarding nearby
Bicycle rentals nearby
Hiking/biking trails nearby
Kayaking nearby
Sailing nearby
Scuba diving nearby
Water skiing nearby
Scooter/moped rentals nearby
Library
Rafting nearby
Safe-deposit box at front desk
Multilingual staff
Express check-out
Parasailing nearby
Skydiving nearby
Ecotours nearby
Tours/ticket assistance
Wheelchair accessible parking
Area shuttle (surcharge)
Snack bar/deli
Access to nearby outdoor pool
Beach umbrellas
Beach cabanas (surcharge)
Beach sun loungers
Pool sun loungers
Beach towels
Boat tours nearby
24-hour pool access
Water dispenser
Proposal/romance packages available
Motor boating nearby
Fishing nearby
Health or beauty spa nearby
Personal motor watercraft nearby
Marina nearby
Swimming nearby
Coin laundry on site
Wheelchair-accessible public washroom
Wheelchair-accessible van parking
Wheelchair-accessible spa
Wheelchair-accessible pool
Wheelchair-accessible on-site restaurant
Accessible shuttle
No accessible shuttle
Free WiFi
Terrace
Garden
Luggage storage
Express check-in/check-out
Designated smoking area
Concierge service
Wheelchair accessible
Picnic area

Good to know

Check-in after 4:00 PM · Check-out before 10:00 AM

Pets allowed · Adults only

Independent

24-hour pool accessContactless check-in and contactless check-out are available.A deposit may be required at the property.

Location

Map showing Amsterdam's Curry Mansion Inn

511 Caroline St, Key West, Florida, 33040, Key West

Reviews

9.2/10Excellent195 reviews

Review highlights

Excellent locationVery clean and comfortable roomsLack of onsite amenitiesOccasional noise from nearby bars
Cleanliness8.6/10
While the hotel was noted to be super clean, one review mentioned needing more attention to cleaning.
Service9.6/10
Staff was responsive, though not always present on site.
Location10.0/10
Excellent location, steps from Duval Street.
Room Quality9.6/10
Most rooms were described as huge and very comfortable.
Amenities8.6/10
Amenities like parking were appreciated, but the lack of onsite staff and a restaurant were noted as downsides.
Value for Money9.6/10
Reasonable value compared to location and overall stay experience.
Food and Beverage8.1/10
No restaurant on site and during renovation, affecting dining options.

Summary written by Anywayr from 195 guest reviews.

G6723SCjimgMarch 2026 · Couples · Tripadvisor

2.0/10

Just Say No I've been to Key West 26 times and stayed in approximately 20 different establishments and this is the worst. No on premises staff. Carpet smells like urine. No ability to leave your luggage at the front desk until check in time. This is a great place for spring breakers that want to put 6 people in a double room, but it's an epic POS for anyone else. Also, I've stayed at two Brightwood properties. The other one was the second worst place I've stayed in Key West. Avoid at all costs. On the other hand, the pool/deck area is probably middle of the pack to similarly priced hotels.

divingtravellerMarch 2026 · Couples · Tripadvisor

2.0/10

Stay elsewhere. There is no front desk, and Security is very lax. Anyone can get to your door at any time of the night, which happened to us. There was no housekeeping, and they did not even supply tissues. Property is very rundown and needs a complete renovation. Previous stays were wonderful, but that was five years ago. Parking is a nightmare as there are not nearly enough spots for everyone.

bonnieu2021February 2026 · Couples · Tripadvisor

4.0/10

Not a good experience. This was NOT a good experience! There was no front desk, and they didn't answer the phone. We had no heat and it was 63 degrees in the room. After 2 days they gave us a portable heater, but didn't have one for my sister in another room. The fire alarm went off at around midnight and the fire department at first couldn't stop it because there was nobody there to open the room with the turn off switch. A bunch of people outside in their pajamas and cold. The fire alarm went off again the next day. A sink was clogged, a lamp broken. I think they watered down the soap, shampoo & conditioner. You can hear music until very late. On the positive side, the housekeeper was very nice, and the maintenance man fixed everything eventually - except the heat - there is no heat. It also is in a very good location.

judithmO8010OQFebruary 2026 · Couples · Tripadvisor

2.0/10

Very disappointed Cannot recommend Curry Mansion. Our balcony has two tiny chairs and a view of the parking lot. Very noisy. In a motel like room with exterior doors. Hear everyone coming in and out of pool area going to their rooms. No staff on site at all! Worst of all the fire alarm went off for 30 minutes at 11:30 pm and no one on site to unlock doors the fire department wanted to get in to. No happy hour or breakfast with room rate as in previous years. No replenishment of towels or room cleaning. You’re paying for location only. Will not return here.

Wander33990386211January 2026 · Couples · Tripadvisor

2.0/10

Avoid We have a tour of some various US locations in celebration of a 70th year this year. As part of our tour we wanted to celebrate by visiting Key West Florida & booked as well as paying to stay at this accommodation. We like the sound of this place ie location, atmosphere etc etc. Some 7/8 weeks after paying but still another 9 months before staying, I received a message through Hotels.com web that is detailed below asking me to cancel & rebook ( at an additional cost of approximately $1000 extra!!!!!!! ) I was gob smacked so I asked Hotels.com to investigate despite them not knowing anything about this matter. I also asked the hotel for documentary evidence that they relied on to support this issue. Nothing came forward from the hotel/Brightwell & Hotels.com said there was nothing that they were prepared to do. I cancelled my booking, got my refund & found another hotel that I hope will not employ this type of tactic. If an agency working on the behalf of a hotel made this kind of error, I would expect the 2 businesses to come up with something between themselves to resolve their error & NOT expect the client to stump up Amsterdam's Curry Mansion Inn sent you a message: Amsterdam's Curry Mansion Inn sent you a message: Hi Russell, Thank you so much for choosing to stay with Brightwild. We wanted to reach out and let you know that we discovered a system error that caused some of our promotional rates to display much lower than the correct pricing. We’re truly sorry for the inconvenience — we understand how frustrating unexpected changes can be. To ensure you're taken care of, we’re offering two options: A full refund if you’d prefer to cancel, or The opportunity to rebook at the accurate rate, and we’ll be happy to assist you step-by-step. We truly value your understanding and patience. Please let us know how you’d like to proceed — we’re here to help in any way we can.

Culture27736682405November 2025 · Friends getaway · Tripadvisor

4.0/10

Location ideal but….. The mansion is beautiful but if you stay in the old part of the house be prepared for rooms that are in desperate need of a good cleaning. The molding is beautiful but hadn’t been dusted in a long time! The electrical in the bathroom could no way meet any kind of code. The hallways and stairs are in need of lighting. There is no one on site to answer any questions. You are on your own. Location is ideal!

rhondas677October 2025 · Couples · Tripadvisor

10.0/10

Wonderful Inn! The Curry Mansion Inn was more than we could have ever have hoped for. We stayed in a Poolside room (#116) of the main location (There is another location across the street called the James House). There was actually parking ON SITE!! If you have ever been to Key West then you know that FREE parking is very limited and we were thrilled to snag a spot (there are not many available but you could get luck like us). The location is AMAZING! Literally walk out of the front doors, turn right and BOOM you are on Duvall Street right behind Fogarty's restaurant. Our room was HUGE and everything we could have asked for. The pool is small but it's perfect for relaxing after exploring the island all day. Unfortunately when we were there they were renovating the restaurant so we didn't get to have that experience. But they even have a laundry facility available if you don't want to go home with dirty clothes. We can't wait to go back this spring!

KellyOctober 2025 · Partner

10.0/10

Right in the middle of everything yet quiet at night. Beautiful room and helpful staff via text.

DanielleSeptember 2025 · Family

8.0/10

Its a old house refurbished into a hotel so electric, water pressure and staff were very little. No food on premises even tho website says their was. 4 Parking spaces and 1 handcap space. You are half block from Duval so you hear music & crowds But overall we enjoyed our stay.

LeeSeptember 2025 · Partner

8.0/10

Great room and very centrally located. Staff tho not on sight was responsive. Bass music noise from neighboring bar until midnight each night was annoying.

Nearby hotels in Key West